Uber Employment ruling.

Uber Drivers, Worker Status and the Gig Economy

The way a business describes someone in a contract does not necessarily determine their legal employment status.

A person described as self-employed or an independent contractor may, in practice, be a worker or employee and therefore entitled to employment rights including the National Minimum Wage and paid holiday.

This principle was confirmed by the Supreme Court in the important case of Uber BV and others v Aslam and others.

What Did the Supreme Court Decide?

On 19 February 2021, the Supreme Court unanimously dismissed Uber's appeal and upheld the finding that the claimant drivers were workers.

The Court decided that their status should be determined by employment legislation and the practical reality of the relationship, rather than relying primarily on the written agreements prepared by Uber.

The drivers were not found to be employees. They belonged to the intermediate legal category of worker.

When Were the Uber Drivers Working?

The Supreme Court upheld the finding that the drivers were working when they:

• had the Uber application switched on;
• were within the area in which they were authorised to work; and
• were ready and willing to accept passenger journeys.

Working time was therefore not limited to the period when a passenger was physically inside the vehicle.

This was important when calculating National Minimum Wage and holiday-pay entitlement.

Why Were the Drivers Treated as Workers?

The Court identified several features showing that Uber exercised substantial control over the service provided by the drivers.

These included:

• Uber setting the fare and therefore controlling how much drivers could earn from each journey;
• Uber determining the contractual terms on which drivers provided services;
• the application controlling or monitoring whether drivers accepted journey requests;
• drivers potentially being penalised for repeatedly refusing or cancelling trips;
• Uber exercising significant control through passenger ratings; and
• Uber restricting direct contact between drivers and passengers beyond what was needed to complete the journey.

The Court concluded that the drivers were in a position of dependency and subordination and had little ability to improve their financial position through individual business skill.

What Is a Worker?

UK employment law generally recognises three principal categories:

• employees;
• workers; and
• genuinely self-employed people.

A worker commonly agrees to perform work or services personally for another party that is not genuinely a customer or client of the worker's own business.

Workers receive significant statutory rights, although they do not automatically receive every right available to employees.

What Rights Does a Worker Receive?

Worker status can provide rights including:

• the National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage;
• paid annual leave;
• rest breaks;
• limits on average weekly working time, subject to any lawful opt-out;
• protection against unlawful deductions from wages;
• protection for whistleblowing;
• protection against unlawful discrimination;
• rights relating to part-time working; and
• workplace pension rights where the eligibility conditions are met.

A worker is also normally entitled to a written statement setting out the principal particulars of the working relationship.

What Rights Do Workers Not Automatically Receive?

Worker status is not the same as employee status.

A worker does not automatically receive rights that depend upon being an employee, such as:

• ordinary unfair dismissal protection;
• a statutory redundancy payment;
• minimum statutory notice of dismissal;
• some family-leave rights; or
• the full range of statutory employment protections available to employees.

Some rights also require a minimum period of continuous employment or other qualifying conditions.

National Minimum Wage

Workers are normally entitled to at least the applicable National Minimum Wage for their working time.

From 1 April 2026, the National Living Wage for workers aged 21 and over is £12.71 an hour.

Lower age-related and apprentice rates apply to some younger workers.

The calculation can be complicated where a person:

• is waiting for work;
• works through an application;
• pays their own expenses;
• uses their own vehicle or equipment;
• works for more than one platform; or
• receives variable fees or incentives.

Not every business expense can be deducted from pay when deciding whether the minimum wage has been paid.

Holiday Pay

Workers are normally entitled to 5.6 weeks of paid statutory annual leave each leave year, calculated in proportion to the amount they work.

Holiday pay should reflect the pay the worker would normally receive, subject to the applicable statutory calculation rules.

Irregular-hours and part-year workers are subject to specific rules governing the accrual and payment of holiday entitlement.

A business cannot normally avoid holiday-pay obligations merely by describing the payment as included within an ordinary fee unless the applicable rolled-up holiday-pay rules are lawfully followed.

Workplace Pensions

Worker status may also bring the person within the workplace pension automatic-enrolment regime.

An organisation must generally automatically enrol an eligible worker where the person:

• is aged from 22 to State Pension age;
• usually works in the UK; and
• earns at least the applicable annual earnings trigger, currently £10,000.

Other workers may have a right to opt into or join a pension scheme even if they do not meet all the automatic-enrolment conditions.

Did the Uber Decision Apply to Every Driver?

The Supreme Court determined the status of the claimant drivers under the working arrangements examined in that case.

It did not issue a declaration that every private-hire driver, courier or person using an online platform must always be treated as a worker.

The legal status of another person will depend on:

• the terms under which they work;
• how those terms operate in practice;
• the amount of control exercised by the business;
• whether personal service is required;
• whether substitution is genuine;
• whether the person can negotiate their fees;
• whether they are running an independent business; and
• the degree of dependency between the parties.

The Written Contract Is Not Conclusive

A contract may state that someone is self-employed, but a tribunal will examine the practical reality of the arrangement.

Businesses cannot necessarily avoid statutory protections by inserting terms stating that:

• the person is an independent contractor;
• no worker relationship exists;
• the parties do not intend to create employment rights; or
• the individual is operating a separate business.

Such wording may be relevant, but it will not determine status where it conflicts with the legislation and the way the work is actually controlled.

Control and Dependency

Control is often an important indication of worker or employee status.

Relevant questions may include:

• Who decides the price charged to the customer?
• Can the individual negotiate their own rate?
• Who decides how the work must be performed?
• Can assignments be refused without penalty?
• Does the platform monitor performance?
• Can access to work be suspended?
• Who owns the customer relationship?
• Can the individual build their own customer base?
• Is the individual genuinely exposed to business risk?

Flexibility over working hours does not by itself prove that someone is self-employed.

Personal Service and Substitution

A genuine right to send another suitably qualified person to carry out the work can be strong evidence against worker status.

However, a substitution clause may carry little weight where it is:

• never permitted in practice;
• subject to extensive approval;
• available only in exceptional circumstances;
• inconsistent with the actual working arrangement; or
• included merely to give the appearance of self-employment.

The tribunal will examine whether the individual is genuinely free to provide a substitute rather than relying only on the wording of the contract.

The Deliveroo Decision

The outcome in the Uber litigation does not mean that all delivery riders have worker status.

In a separate case concerning Deliveroo riders and trade union recognition, the Supreme Court upheld the finding that the riders were not workers for the relevant collective bargaining legislation.

A significant factor was their broad and genuine right to use substitutes, including people who had not previously been approved by Deliveroo.

The contrasting decisions demonstrate that status depends on the detailed reality of each business model.

Can Gig Workers Join a Trade Union?

People working in the gig economy can join a trade union.

However, the right to require a business to recognise a union for collective bargaining can depend on whether the individuals fall within the relevant statutory definition of worker.

Even without statutory recognition, a union may assist members by:

• providing advice;
• supporting legal cases;
• organising collective campaigns;
• representing members in disputes; and
• negotiating voluntarily with a platform or business.

Employment Status and Tax Status

Employment status for statutory workplace rights and status for tax purposes are related but separate legal questions.

A person may be treated in one way for employment-rights purposes and differently under tax legislation.

An employment tribunal finding that someone is a worker does not necessarily determine every PAYE, National Insurance or tax issue.

Businesses and individuals may need separate employment-law and tax advice.

Can Workers Claim Back Pay?

A person wrongly treated as self-employed may be able to claim money including:

• underpaid National Minimum Wage;
• unpaid holiday pay;
• unlawful deductions from wages;
• pension contributions in appropriate cases; and
• compensation for other infringed worker rights.

The amount recoverable will depend on the legal basis of the claim, the relevant time limits and the available records.

Claims do not necessarily arise automatically for every person performing similar work. An agreement, tribunal judgment or another enforcement process may still be required.

Keeping Evidence

A person concerned about their employment status should retain evidence including:

• contracts and written terms;
• application screenshots;
• records of hours logged in;
• accepted and refused assignments;
• ratings and performance warnings;
• payment statements;
• expenses;
• messages from managers or platform operators;
• records of suspensions or penalties; and
• evidence showing the degree of control over the work.

The practical working arrangements may be more important than the label used in the agreement.

Employment Tribunal Time Limits

Employment tribunal time limits are usually short.

Many claims concerning wages, holiday pay or employment status must normally be started within three months less one day of the relevant act, deduction or termination of the working relationship.

Before bringing most tribunal claims, the claimant must contact Acas for Early Conciliation.

The Early Conciliation process usually pauses the tribunal limitation period, but calculating the final deadline can be complicated.

A worker should not delay while continuing an internal complaint or waiting for the business to investigate.

Enforcing the National Minimum Wage

The National Minimum Wage can be enforced by HM Revenue and Customs or through legal proceedings brought by the worker.

Where underpayment is established, the employer may be required to:

• pay arrears;
• pay a financial penalty;
• correct its records and working practices; and
• respond to tribunal or court proceedings.

It is unlawful to dismiss or subject a worker to certain detrimental treatment because they seek to enforce minimum-wage rights.

Advantages of Gig-Economy Work

Gig-economy arrangements can provide genuine benefits, including:

• flexibility over when to work;
• the ability to use several platforms;
• opportunities to supplement other income;
• a relatively simple route into paid work; and
• greater choice over the quantity of work accepted.

Worker status does not necessarily require all flexibility to be removed.

The legal question is whether flexibility is accompanied by sufficient protection where the individual is working personally within a business controlled by another organisation.

Concerns About the Gig Economy

Critics argue that some gig-economy models transfer substantial costs and risks to individuals while the platform retains control over price, access to customers and performance.

Potential concerns include:

• income falling below the minimum wage after working time and expenses are considered;
• no payment for holiday;
• unpredictable earnings;
• automatic suspension or termination;
• limited opportunity to challenge ratings or decisions;
• lack of pension provision;
• workers bearing vehicle, fuel and insurance costs; and
• uncertainty about legal rights.

Businesses argue that imposing a traditional employment model may reduce flexibility, increase prices and limit the number of work opportunities available.

What Should Businesses Do?

A business engaging contractors or platform workers should regularly review:

• how much control it exercises;
• whether personal service is required;
• whether substitution rights are genuine;
• how pay is calculated;
• whether waiting time counts as work;
• holiday-pay arrangements;
• minimum-wage compliance;
• pension duties;
• termination and suspension procedures; and
• whether written terms reflect the working reality.

Changing the contract without changing the practical relationship may not prevent a status claim.

What Should a Worker Do?

A person who believes they have been incorrectly classified should:

• compare the written terms with what happens in practice;
• keep records of hours, payments and expenses;
• ask the business to explain its status decision;
• check minimum-wage and holiday-pay calculations;
• contact Acas promptly;
• consider reporting pension concerns to The Pensions Regulator; and
• obtain legal advice before the tribunal time limit expires.

The Current Position

The Uber case is no longer awaiting appeal. The Supreme Court's 2021 judgment was the final determination of the appeal.

The claimant drivers were workers, rather than employees or genuinely independent contractors, under the arrangements considered by the courts.

The decision confirmed that employment status is determined by legislation and the true working relationship. A business cannot necessarily remove statutory rights merely by describing someone as self-employed.

However, the judgment did not give every person in the gig economy identical status. Each arrangement must be examined individually.

Finding an Employment Law Solicitor

Use the search facility at the top of this page to find an employment law solicitor who can advise on worker status, self-employment, holiday pay, minimum-wage arrears, workplace pensions or employment tribunal claims.

Disclaimer

Solicitors.com is not a firm of solicitors. This article provides general information about employment status and gig-economy work in Great Britain and does not constitute legal or tax advice. Employment status depends on the facts of each working relationship, and tribunal time limits can be short.

Feedback

If you believe this page contains an error or requires updating, please get in touch with us. We welcome amendments that help keep our legal information accurate and useful.